1964-65 Our Town

1965-66 Three One Act Plays

1966-67 Ten Little Indians

1967-68 Charlie’s Aunt, Brigadoon

1968-69 See How they Run, 100 Degrees in the Shade

1969-70 Johnny Belinda, Little Mary Sunshine

1970-71 The Skin of Our Teeth, The Boy Friend

1971-72 Harvey, The King and I

1972-73 Enter Laughing, Carousel

1973-74 Arsenic and Old Lace, Bye Bye Birdie

1974-75 Androcles and the Lion, Guys and Dolls

1975-76 Up the Down Staircase, Annie Get Your Gun

1967-77 Fantasy, The Wizard of Oz

1977-78 David and Lisa, Oliver

1978-79 A Night of One Acts, Godspell

1979-80 The Night of January 16th, Hello Dolly!

1980-81 The Late Great Me

1981-82 The Apple Tree

1982-83 Godspell

1983-84 Scenes from Shakespeare

1985-86 George Washington Slept Here

1986-87 Sherlock Holmes

1987-88 You Can’t Take it with You

1988-89 Inherit the Wind

1989-90 Jabberwock

1990-91 Stage Door

1991-92 Desk Set

1992-93 Blue Collar Blues, Carnival!

1993-94 Hobson’s Choice, Little Me

1994-95 Ah, Wilderness!, How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying

1995-96 Three Men on a Horse, Sound of Music

1996-97 Ghost Train, Bye Bye Birdie

1997-98 The Musical Comedy Murders of 1940, Little Shop of Horrors

1998-99 Don’t Drink the Water, Guys and Dolls

1999-00 The Visit, The Will Rogers Follies

2000-01 The Rivals, Into the Woods

2001-02 The Witching Hour, Anything Goes

2002-03 The Teahouse of the August Moon, 42nd Street

2003-04 The Odd Couple, How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying

2004-05 Epic Proportions, Godspell

2005-06 Arsenic & Old Lace, Seussical

2006-07 Romeo & Juliet, Little Shop of Horrors

2007-08 Inspecting Carol, Thoroughly Modern Millie

2008-09 Miss Nelson is Missing, Grease

2009-10 Once Upon a Pandora’s Box, Cinderella

2010-11 Snow Queen, Oklahoma

2011-12 Charlie & The Chocolate Factory, Alter Idol, Bye Bye Birdie

2012-13 The Bad Seed, Alter Idol, Beauty and the Beast

2013-14 Boeing Boeing, Alter’s Got Talent, Children of Eden

2014-15 The Musical Comedy Murders of 1940, Alter’s Got Talent, Into the Woods

2015-16 Blithe Spirit, Alter’s Got Talent, Aida

2016-17 And Then They Came For Me, Alter’s Got Talent, The Drowsy Chaperone

2017-18 Lost In Yonkers, Alter’s Got Talent, Godspell

2018-19 The Alumni Showcase, The Guys, Steel Magnolias, Songs For A New World, Alter’s Got Talent, Thoroughly Modern Millie

2019-20 26 Pebbles, Freaky Friday, Alter’s Got Talent, Once on This Island

2020-21 Proof, Breaking the Fifth Wall: Theatre in a New Age, From Now On (music video), Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat

2021-22 The Play That Goes Wrong, The Lightning Thief, Disney’s Newsies, “Louder Than Words” (Music Video)

2022-23 Clue, The Anxiety Project, Singing in the Rain, “Indestructible” (music video)

2023-24 The Spitfire Grill, The Audition, Disney’s Beauty and the Beast

2025 Reese Hornick and Nate Miller

2025 – Reese Hornick and Nate Miller

2024 – Simon Roth and Sophia Shenk

2023– Eric Pettit and Mikayla Mihok

2022– Nick Abouzeid and Megan Lapp

2021– Sam Johnson and Annabel Wildermuth

2020– Sara LiBrandi

2019– Riley Francis

2018– Kevin Woeste

2017– Bridget Miley

2016– Alyssa Fasoli

2015– Meghan Rupper

2014– Lauren DiMario